Americus Rugged ATR vs Atturo Trail Blade ATS tires

Americus Tires and Atturo Tires are two popular tire manufacturers offering a range of good quality and affordable tires for various fitments. Americus Tires were founded in 1900 and were built for American roads by the American Omni Trading Company. The brand focuses on quality and offers superb performance at affordable rates in the American market. Atturo Tires is a relatively new brand founded in 2009 and produces high-quality tires that blend quiet, comfortable on-road performance with enhanced off-road capabilities. Both brands offer a range of tires in different categories such as all-season, all-weather, ultra-high-performance, winter, highway, all-terrain, and many more.

All-terrain tires are designed for use on light trucks, SUVs, and Jeeps, and offer drivers enhanced traction on challenging terrain, improved durability to protect the tire, and consistent handling. Today we will look at two great all-terrain tires from the brands - Americus Rugged ATR, and Atturo Trail Blade ATS. Both these tires are all-terrain tires designed for use on SUVs, light trucks, and Jeeps. We will discuss a few similarities and differences between these two tires in this Americus Rugged ATR vs Atturo Trail Blade ATS tire comparison.

Americus Rugged ATR tires

The Americus Rugged ATR is an all-terrain tire that is designed for use on light trucks, SUVs, and Jeeps to offer next-generation design, and features in a robust tire. The tire features a combination of rigid interior tread blocks and a 3D sipe pattern that enhances wet-weather traction and a high void tread pattern that ejects debris from the tire. The Americus Rugged ATR is also backed by a 45,000 mile limited manufacturer tread life warranty, making it a great choice for your vehicle.

All of these features have allowed us to give Americus Rugged ATR an average SimpleScore of 7.9 out of 10.

Atturo Trail Blade ATS tires

The Atturo Trail Blade ATS is an all-terrain tire designed for use on Jeeps, light trucks, and SUVs and features a Quartermaster Knives-inspired sidewall pattern for an aggressive look. The tire is built with a self-cleaning design, and large tread blocks, and is also backed by a 50,000 mile limited manufacturer tread life warranty. The Atturo Trail Blade ATS offers consistent traction and a quiet, comfortable ride, making it a great choice for your vehicle.

The Atturo Trail Blade ATS scored an average SimpleScore of 8 out of 10.

Americus Rugged ATR vs Atturo Trail Blade ATS tires on traction

When choosing tires, traction is crucial because it affects their performance on both wet and dry surfaces, providing stability. Good traction is essential for effective braking, reducing the risk of hydroplaning, and ensuring smooth handling around curves and corners. Factors that influence a tire's traction include the tread design, pattern, rubber compound, and other characteristics.

In traction, the Americus Rugged ATR scored a good score of 7.8 thanks to the combination of rigid interior tread blocks and a 3D sipe pattern that enhances wet-weather traction. Additionally, the chunky shoulder lugs can be studded, where permitted, to enhance traction during moderate to severe winter weather conditions.

The Atturo Trail Blade ATS scored a great score of 8 in traction thanks to the self-cleaning design that forces mud, dirt, rocks, and other debris out of the tread for consistent traction.

While both tires offer great traction the Atturo Trail Blade ATS scores better, making it the clear winner. However, the Americus tire can be studded, where permitted, for even better traction in moderate to severe winter weather conditions, giving it a competitive advantage.

ADVANTAGE: Atturo Trail Blade ATS

Americus Rugged ATR vs Atturo Trail Blade ATS tires on handling

When selecting tires, prioritizing handling is crucial because it greatly affects vehicle control, especially at high speeds. Superior handling ensures smooth maneuvering, effortless lane changes, and an overall enjoyable driving experience. Key elements such as tread design, rubber formulation, and advanced technology integration in the tire's construction play a significant role in shaping its handling performance.

The Americus Rugged ATR scored a great score of 8 in handling, thanks to the 3D siping technology and rigid interior tread blocks. In handling, the Atturo Trail Blade ATS scored a great score of 8.2, thanks to the large tread blocks and multiple sipes that enhance traction, and handling performance.

In traction, both tires perform similarly and offer responsive handling when driving on paved or unpaved roads. However, based on the SimpleScore, the Atturo Trail Blade ATS is the winner.

ADVANTAGE: Atturo Trail Blade ATS

Americus Rugged ATR vs Atturo Trail Blade ATS tires on longevity

When selecting tires, drivers prioritize longevity since it directly influences how far they can travel on a single set. Due to the unavoidable wear and tear, choosing durable tires is essential for maintaining consistent handling and traction over time. Factors such as tread design, rubber composition, and tire construction all play a crucial role in determining a tire's lifespan.

In longevity, the Americus Rugged ATR scored a great score of 8.1 thanks to the unique wear-resistant rubber compound paired with a 45,000 mile limited manufacturer tread life warranty.

The Atturo Trail Blade ATS shines in longevity with a great score of 8.5 thanks to the wear-resistant rubber compound. The tire is also backed by a 50,000 mile limited manufacturer tread life warranty.

In longevity, the Atturo Trail Blade ATS is the clear winner as it scores slightly better on SimpleScore, and also offers a better mileage warranty.

ADVANTAGE: Atturo Trail Blade ATS

When to use each

Both Americus Rugged ATR and Atturo Trail Blade ATS are great all-terrain tires designed for use on SUVs, light trucks, and Jeeps. Both tires offer consistent and responsive traction, robust handling, and longer tread life and can be used on paved and unpaved roads. The Americus tire can also be pinned, where permitted, to offer even better traction on icy and snow-covered roads. Finally, both tires are backed by varying tread life warranties, ensuring a longer tread life.

Which one should you choose?

So, which all-terrain tire might be the right fit for you? Well, the answer depends on your personal preference as both tires come with their own set of advantages and disadvantages. For instance, the Atturo Trail Blade ATS scores better in overall SimpleScore, traction, handling, and longevity but cannot be pinned for better winter traction. On the other hand, the Americus Rugged ATR can be pinned, where permitted, but falls short on overall performance slightly.

Another important factor to consider when purchasing tires is the price. The Americus Rugged ATR costs $150.98 per tire or $603.92 for a set of four. The Atturo Trail Blade ATS costs $124.17 per tire or $496.68 for a set of four.

Based on SimpleScore, you should choose Americus Rugged ATR if you:

• Drive a vehicle like the 2018 Toyota Tacoma or the 2016 Ram 1500
• Want a tire that can be pinned, where permitted, for enhanced snow traction
• Are willing to pay slightly more for great performance

Based on SimpleScore, you should choose Atturo Trail Blade ATS if you:

• Drive a Jeep like the 2017 Toyota 4Runner, or a 2019 Ford F-250 Super Duty
• Want a set of tires with better SimpleScore (8 v 7.9), traction (8 v 7.8), handling (8.2 v 8), and longevity (8.5 v 8.1)
• Want a better set of tires at a slightly lower price

Still not sure which tire to buy? Fortunately, SimpleTire is here to help as our helpful agents are more than happy to assist you in selecting the right tire for your ride and budget.