Atturo Trail Blade A/T vs Thunderer Ranger A/T R404 tires

Atturo, which has over 80 years of tire manufacturing history, began operations in Illinois in 2009 and specializes in manufacturing great tires for light trucks and SUVs. The Thailand-based Thunderer is a Deestone affiliate brand, and their tires are specifically intended and engineered for North American drivers. Today, Atturo offers all-terrain light truck tires under the Trail Blade brand; the AZ Series for passenger vehicles, commercial vehicle tires, and Powersports tires for SxS and ATV vehicles. On the other hand, Thunderer provides passenger tires under the Mach badge, light truck or SUV tires in the Ranger family, and specialist, commercial, and trailer tires at an affordable price.

Designed for light trucks and SUVs, the Atturo Trail Blade A/T is an all-terrain tire that offers traction and performance on- and off- the road. The Trail Blade A/T's heavy-duty carcass increases load-carrying capacity, while a robust rubber compound protects the tire from harm and extends its tread life.

An all-terrain tire, the Thunderer Ranger A/T R404 is designed for use on light trucks and offers great responsiveness and road manners on the highway. The aggressive tread pattern provides solid traction and handling both on- and off-road and the rim guard and reinforced sidewall protect the tire and wheel from harm.

Performance-wise, the Atturo Trail Blade A/T and the Thunderer Ranger A/T R404 are very similar. However, how are these tires different from one another? Here is a comparison of the handling, traction, and longevity of the Atturo Trail Blade A/T and the Thunderer Ranger A/T R404 using SimpleScore (SimpleTire's proprietary tire rating system).

Atturo Trail Blade A/T tires

Perfect for both daily drivers and weekend adventurers, the Atturo Trail Blade A/T is a durable all-terrain tire designed for work or adventure. It meets the needs for strength, durability, and all-terrain performance and is Three Peak Mountain Snowflake certified. Its wide channel vacuum water from the contact patch and jagged sipes provide good wet traction, and interlocked center tread controls boost stability.

On average, the Atturo Trail Blade A/T sports a good SimpleScore (7.8) thanks to its great longevity (8), solid handling (7.8), and good traction (7.7).

Thunderer Ranger A/T R404 tires

The Ranger A/T R404 is an all-terrain tire with a unique tread pattern that maximizes traction edges for improved handling on and off the road. A closed shoulder allows for confident handling in all conditions. Deep grooves provide superior hydroplaning resistance and wet traction and the unique tread shape allows for responsive steering and turning. In addition, its rim guards protect the tire from external harm.

On average, the Thunderer Ranger A/T has an overall SimpleScore of (7.8) because of its impressive longevity (8), decent handling (7.8), and solid traction (7.6).

Atturo Trail Blade A/T vs Thunderer Ranger A/T R404 tires on traction

All-terrain tires, which are commonly used on light trucks, jeeps, and SUVs, are designed to provide drivers with good traction and performance both on and off-road. Let’s check out the traction scores of the Atturo Trail Blade A/T and the Thunderer Ranger A/T R404.

The Atturo Trail Blade A/T has a traction score of 7.7 thanks to a network of sipes, hundreds of hair-thin slits in the tread that improve traction in wet or snowy situations. Wide grooves fend off water from the footprint, lowering the chance of hydroplaning on wet surfaces and boosting wet traction.

Likewise, the Thunderer Ranger A/T R404 has a traction score of 7.6 thanks to its aggressive tread pattern that provides off-road traction. In addition, its four deep and wide grooves drain water from the tread, lowering the risk of hydroplaning on wet roads and increasing wet traction.

When compared side by side, the Thunderer Ranger A/T R404 receives a good score of 7.6, but Atturo Trail Blade A/T surpasses it with a score of 7.7.

ADVANTAGE: Atturo Trail Blade A/T

Atturo Trail Blade A/T vs Thunderer Ranger A/T R404 tires on handling

All-terrain tires are a fantastic option for drivers who alternate between paved roads and off-road settings since they are made to handle a range of driving circumstances, including those that occur on and off the road. How do the Trail Blade A/T and the Ranger A/T R404 compare against each other when it comes to handling? Let’s check out.

The Atturo Trail Blade A/T features large shoulder blocks that improve handling performance and achieve a 7.8 handling score.

Similarly, the Thunderer Ranger A/T R404 sports a handling score of 7.8, thanks to its aggressive tread pattern and multiple sipes.

When it comes to handling, the Trail Blade A/T and the Ranger A/T R404 have their scores leveled.

ADVANTAGE: Tie

Atturo Trail Blade A/T vs Thunderer Ranger A/T R404 tires on longevity

Longevity is a vital factor in determining the quality of an all-terrain tire. How do the Atturo Trail Blade A/T and the Thunderer Ranger A/T R404 fare against each other in this aspect? Let’s see:

Backed by a 50,000 mile limited manufacturer tread life warranty, the TrailBlade A/T features stone throwers to improve debris ejection and protect the casing. A robust rubber compound protects the tire from damage, resulting in a longer tread life. It has a great longevity score of 8.

Similarly, the Thunderer Ranger A/T R404 features a long-lasting rubber compound that guards against cuts, chips, and abrasions and comes with a 55,000 mile limited manufacturer tread life warranty. Additionally, its strengthened sidewall and rim protector prevent damage to the tire. As a result, the Ranger A/T R404 earns a longevity score of 8.

For longevity, too, the Trail Blade A/T and the Ranger A/T R404 have identical SimpleScores of 8.

ADVANTAGE: Tie

When to use each

All-terrain tires are designed to provide good handling and traction on a variety of surfaces, including paved roads, dirt, and gravel. They are a good choice for drivers who do a mix of on-road and off-road driving. The Atturo Trail Blade A/T and Thunderer Ranger A/T R404 are great all-terrain tires that offer traction both on- and off-road. However, these tires cannot handle muddy terrains and harsh winter weather conditions. Switch to mud-terrain tires for optimum performance in muddy terrains and winter tires to travel in harsh winter weather conditions.

Which one should you choose?

So, which of these all-terrain tires will be a good fit for your vehicle? The Atturo Trail Blade A/T and the Thunderer Ranger A/T R404 perform similarly and have an identical SimpleScore. Let's check their prices to see if there is a difference.

Comparing the prices of the 235/70R16 tire size, the Atturo Trail Blade A/T costs around $97 per tire, and four such tires cost $388, while the Thunderer Ranger A/T R404 costs around $125 per tire and four such tires cost $500 (a difference of $112).

Based on SimpleScore, you should choose the Atturo Trail Blade A/T if you:

• Drive a full-size pickup truck like the Chevrolet Silverado, Ford F-150, or GMC Canyon
• Prefer better traction (7.7 vs 7.6)
• Want an all-terrain tire with reliable performance at less price

Conversely, you should choose the Thunderer Ranger A/T R404 if you:

• Drive a full-sized SUV like the Dodge Dakota or a mid-size crew-cab pickup truck GMC Canyon
• Want a tire with a better mileage warranty (55,000 vs 50,000 miles limited manufacturer tread life warranty)

Atturo and Thunderer make some of the most reliable all-terrain tires in the industry. Both the Atturo Trail Blade A/T and the Thunderer Ranger A/T R404 carry their legacy. They are closely positioned against one another in terms of performance. However, select a tire based on traction, handling, price, and your driving requirements and budget.

Still not sure which tire to buy? Fortunately, SimpleTire is here to help, and our helpful agents will be more than happy to assist you in selecting the right tire for your ride and budget.