Pirelli Cinturato WeatherActive vs Toyo Celsius Sport tires

Pirelli Tires and Toyo Tires are two top tire manufacturers that offer a range of high-quality and reliable tires for passenger and commercial vehicles. Pirelli with over 150 years of experience is the fifth-largest tire manufacturer in the world and has a lengthy history with car racing events, and supercars. Toyo Tires made their debut in the US market in 1966 and thanks to their innovation and quality, quickly became a popular tire partner for most of the country’s light trucks. Both brands offer a large selection of tires in different categories such as all-season, UHP, summer, winter, all-weather, highway, and so on.

All-weather tires are designed to be used throughout the year in dry, wet, and winter weather conditions. Like all-season tires, these tires offer consistent traction, extended longevity, and responsive handling, with the added advantage of robust traction in moderate to heavy winter conditions. Today, we will be comparing two leading all-weather tires from the brands - Pirelli Cinturato WeatherActive and Toyo Celsius Sport. Both tires are designed to be used on passenger cars and offer excellent performance in dry, wet, and winter conditions. We will be looking at some of the similarities, and differences between these two tires in this Pirelli Cinturato WeatherActive vs Toyo Celsius Sport tire comparison.

Pirelli Cinturato WeatherActive tires

The Pirelli Cinturato WeatherActive is an all-weather tire designed for use on passenger cars and offers drivers excellent traction and performance in dry, wet, and winter weather conditions. The tire features a directional tread pattern, trumpet-shaped lateral grooves, a special tread pattern, and various features. Additionally, the tire is backed by a 60,000 mile limited manufacturer tread life warranty and is Three Peak Mountain Snowflake certified for use in moderate to severe winter weather conditions.

All these features have allowed us to rate the Pirelli Cinturato WeatherActive an excellent average SimpleScore of 9.6 out of 10.

Toyo Celsius Sport tires

The Toyo Celsius Sport is an all-weather tire designed for use on CUVs, SUVs, and performance-based luxury cars to offer drivers solid year-round traction and grip. The tire also ensures better driving comfort and handling with consistent wear performance. Also, Three Peak Mountain Snowflake certified, the Toyo Celsius Sport is backed by a 60,000 miles limited manufacturer tread life warranty and Toyo’s 500-Mile or 45-Day Trial, and Mileage Warranty (restrictions and limitations apply).

Thanks to these features, the Toyo Celsius Sport received an average SimpleScore of 8.6 out of 10.

Pirelli Cinturato WeatherActive vs Toyo Celsius Sport tires on traction

When buying tires, it's crucial to think about traction. This factor dictates how well the tires can grasp the road, whether it's dry or wet, ensuring optimal control. Traction impacts braking efficiency, resistance to hydroplaning, and maneuverability, all pivotal for safe driving. Several factors, like tread pattern, tire design, and rubber compound formulation, collaborate to determine the tire's traction capability.

In traction, the Pirelli Cinturato WeatherActive scored an excellent score of 9.8 thanks to the trumpet-shaped lateral grooves that force water out of the tread for reduced risk of hydroplaning. Additionally, the tire comes with deep and continuous sipes that bite into the road for enhanced traction. This tire is also Three Peak Mountain Snowflake certified, meaning it will offer consistent traction, and responsive handling on snow-covered roads.

The Toyo Celsius Sport scored a great score of 8.5 in traction thanks to the interlocking multi-wave sipes bite into the road for better braking and traction paired with wide grooves with traction bars which further improve wet grip. Moreover, the specialized silica compound keeps the tire flexible in colder temperatures and zigzag-shaped tread blocks with high sipe density enhance winter traction, resulting in a 3PMSF certification for the tire.

While both tires offer great traction, the Cinturato WeatherActive scores considerably higher on SimpleScore, making it a clear winner among the two.

ADVANTAGE: Pirelli Cinturato WeatherActive

Pirelli Cinturato WeatherActive vs. Toyo Celsius Sport tires on handling

When selecting tires, handling is a vital consideration as it directly impacts your command of the vehicle, especially during higher speeds. Effective handling ensures smooth maneuverability, seamless lane changes, and enjoyable driving experiences. This aspect is influenced by factors like tread design, rubber composition, and the incorporation of advanced technology into the tire's construction.

In handling, the Pirelli Cinturato WeatherActive scored an excellent score of 9.8 too thanks to the tire’s zigzag central groove that boosts handling performance on wet roads. Additionally, the directional tread pattern helps lower road noises, and vibrations for a quiet, comfortable ride.

The Toyo Celsius Sport scored a great score of 8.9 in handling thanks to the ultra-high performance casing construction which improves handling and responsiveness. Additionally, it boosts contact pressure during braking, cornering, and acceleration for even better handling performance.

In handling, the Cinturato WeatherActive has an edge over the Alkimate solely based on SimpleScore. However, as both tires are all-weather tires, they are designed to offer sporty, and responsive handling throughout the year.

ADVANTAGE: Pirelli Cinturation WeatherActive

Pirelli Cinturato WeatherActive vs. Toyo Celsius Sport tires on longevity

Longevity ranks high among drivers' considerations when selecting tires, as it directly impacts the mileage they can achieve on a single set. With consistent use, tread wear becomes inevitable, underscoring the necessity for tires that offer prolonged longevity to maintain peak handling, and traction throughout their lifespan. Factors like tread pattern, rubber composition, and tire design collectively contribute to determining the tire's longevity.

The Pirelli Cinturato WeatherActive scored an excellent score of 9.2 in longevity, thanks to the special rubber compound that prevents uneven tread wear paired with 3-rib tread blocks which keeps the tread blocks stiff to fend off uneven wear. The tire is also backed by a 60,000 mile limited manufacturer tread life warranty.

The Toyo Celsius Sport delivers great longevity performance with a score of 8.6 and is backed by a 60,000 miles limited manufacturer tread life warranty. The asymmetric tread pattern of the tire helps reduce uneven tread wear to deliver a longer tread life.

In longevity, the Cinturato WeatherActive again takes the lead with a higher score. However, both tires offer the same mileage warranty and will deliver value for money with a long tread life.

ADVANTAGE: Pirelli Cinturato WeatherActive

When to use each

Both Pirelli Cinturato WeatherActive and Toyo Celsius Sport are all-weather tires designed to be used throughout the year in wet, dry, or heavy winter weather conditions. These tires are specifically designed to withstand all weather conditions and should be used on paved roads. Lastly, these tires can withstand warmer and colder temperatures efficiently and will offer long tread life, consistent traction, and responsive handling.

Which one should you choose?

So which all-weather tire might be the right choice for you? Well, the answer depends solely on your personal preference as both tires have their set of advantages and disadvantages. However, both tires will offer great overall performance. The Cinturato WeatherActive is a top-of-the-line performance-oriented all-weather tire from Pirelli that delivers excellent performance throughout the year. On the contrary, while the Toyo Celsius Sport delivers great overall performance, its USP lies in its affordability. As seen above, the Pirelli tire trumps in overall SimpleScore, traction, handling, and longevity.

However, another important factor to consider when purchasing a set of tires is the price. While the Pirelli Cinturato WeatherActive costs $220.62 per tire or $882.48 for a set, the Toyo Celsius Sport costs $197.99 per tire or $791.96 for a set of four. (Note: The prices may vary depending on the tire size.)

Based on SimpleScore, you should choose Pirelli Cinturato WeatherActive if you:

• Drive a car like the Audi Q3 or something like the BMW 430i
• Want a tire with better overall SimpleScore (9.6 v 8.6)
• Want a tire with better traction (9.8 v 8.5), longevity (9.2 v 8.6), and handling (9.8 v 8.9)
• Are willing to pay more for a better set of tires

Based on SimpleScore, you should choose the Toyo Celsius Sport if you:

• Drive a car like the Honda CR-V, or a Toyota Corolla
• Want a more affordable set of tires that still offers great overall performance
• Want a tire with brand warranty - Toyo's 500-Mile or 45-Day Trial, and Mileage Warranty (restrictions and limitations apply).

Still unsure which tire to buy? Fortunately, SimpleTire is here to help. Our helpful agents are more than happy to assist you in selecting the right tire for your ride and budget.