Pirelli Scorpion MTR vs General Grabber X3 tires

When it comes to tackling the toughest terrains, Pirelli and General stand out as top contenders in the world of off-road tires. Pirelli, the reputed Italian tire manufacturer, carries a legacy of over 150 years in designing durable tires, while General Tire, an American brand known for its rugged and durable tires, offers high-quality mud-terrains that provide impressive performance and traction on extreme terrains, along with impressive performance in winter and wet conditions.

The Pirelli Scorpion MTR and the General Grabber X3 are two great mud-terrain tires that we are going to pit against each another for a comprehensive comparison. Both tires offer outstanding traction, durability, and handling in the most challenging environments. Whether you drive a Jeep, SUV, or light truck, it’s imperative to choose the right tire for your adventures. Let’s compare the Pirelli Scorpion MTR vs General Grabber X3 based on our proprietary SimpleScore to help you choose the right tire.

Pirelli Scorpion MTR tires

Adding to its extensive lineup of tires, Pirelli introduced its Scorpion MTR in the USA in 2018. These robust tires ensure exceptional performance in sand, mud, loose dirt, gravel, and snow, delivering optimal control amidst the challenges of nature, while offering decent road manners on pavement. The Scorpion MTR comes with large transversal grooves to self-clean the tread of debris and mud. Designed for 4WD vehicles, it features an aggressive high-void tread that eliminates debris and mud, leaving a clear section in the tire to dig in. Thanks to its reinforced sidewalls, robust casing, and rim protection, the mud-terrain tire delivers optimal traction in the most challenging terrains.

With a great SimpleScore of 8.4 out of 10, the Pirelli Scorpion MTR offers fantastic traction, grip, stability, and performance on beaten tracks.

General Grabber X3 tires

Designed for SUVs and light trucks, the General Grabber X3 is a great mud-terrain tire offering extreme off-road traction and aggressive styling in the US since 2016. It excels in dirt, mud, and rocky terrain while delivering impressive winter and wet performance. Featuring the Duragen Technology of General Tire, it boasts durability and strength for enhancing the tread life of the tire. The Grabber X3 is optimized to enhance driving comfort, reduce road noise, and make rides comfortable. Its aggressive tread design ensures excellent traction and performance in the harshest environments, making it a reliable choice for off-road adventures.

With an overall SimpleScore of 8.2 and an attractive black or Smooth Red Letter (SRL) sidewall, the General Grabber X3 stands out, in terms of looks and in parameters like traction, handling, and durability.

Pirelli Scorpion MTR vs General Grabber X3 tires on traction

On off-road tires, drivers look out for great traction as it prevents vehicles from skidding or losing grip on the toughest terrain. Proper traction ensures constant contact of the tire with the road surface. The Pirelli Scorpion MTR and the General Grabber X3 offer impressive traction.

The Pirelli Scorpion MTR bags an excellent traction score of 9.6 thanks to its aggressive high-void tread pattern and large transversal grooves that eliminate mud effectively, allowing the clean section of the tire to dig into the terrain. The dense sipes of the Scorpion MTR boost traction, making it highly effective on gravel, loose dirt, mud, sand, and snow.

In contrast, the General Grabber X3 scores 8.3 in traction as its aggressive tread design offers improved off-road traction in mud, dirt, and rock-covered terrains. Thanks to Duragen Technology, the tire maintains grip in harsh environments, while the optimized tread pattern delivers reliable performance in winter and wet conditions.

Although both mud-terrain tires offer improved traction, the Pirelli Scorpion MTR wins the traction battle with its superior grip and self-cleaning capabilities.

ADVANTAGE: Pirelli Scorpion MTR

Pirelli Scorpion MTR vs General Grabber X3 tires on durability

When it comes to off-road adventures, durability is a crucial factor as it demonstrates the ability of the tire to resist cuts, chips, tears, and abrasions. The Pirelli Scorpion MTR and the General Grabber X3 come with robust features to withstand harsh conditions on challenging terrain.

The Pirelli Scorpion MTR, with its multi-ply construction and reinforced sidewalls, offers good puncture resistance and minimizes the risk of tire damage from debris and sharp rocks, thereby scoring a 9.2. The rim guard offers further protection to the tire, maintaining the integrity of the wheels during off-road adventures.

With a score of 8.4, the General Grabber X3 boasts Duragen Technology which enhances its overall durability. This technology not only improves puncture resistance but also fortifies the tire against cuts, chips, and tears. Thanks to the multi-ply construction of the Grabber X3, off-road enthusiasts benefit from its robust nature, making it a great choice for prolonged off-road use.

In terms of durability, the General Grabber X3 gains an advantage with its comprehensive approach to puncture, cut, chip, and tear resistance, backed by Duragen Technology and multi-ply construction.

ADVANTAGE: Pirelli Scorpion MTR

Pirelli Scorpion MTR vs General Grabber X3 tires on longevity

The mileage of a tire and the number of years it serves determine its actual worth. Thus, longevity is another crucial parameter in our comparison to consider while choosing tires.

At 7.6, the longevity score of the Pirelli Scorpion MTR looks decent, but it scores lower than the other two parameters. While its aggressive tread design may lead to faster wear, especially on paved roads, there are dense sipes to decrease the same.

General Grabber X3, on the other hand, scores 8.4 in longevity. Thanks to Duragen Technology, this mud terrain tire offers greater strength and durability, resisting damage while navigating challenging terrains. The optimized tread pattern of the Grabber X3 reduces uneven wear, ensuring consistent performance over time.

When it comes to longevity, the General Grabber X3 outperforms the Pirelli Scorpion MTR, offering a longer tread life and consistent performance on beaten tracks.

ADVANTAGE: General Grabber X3

When to use each

Mud terrain tires are commonly used on SUVs and light trucks to excel in mud, sand, dirt, rock, and gravel. Engineered to overcome the most extreme challenges of nature, these tires feature aggressive tread designs to conquer any terrain. With reinforced sidewalls, they resist damage during off-roading. Although they are meant for off-road use, you can also use them on paved roads and highways from time to time. If you are looking for a good mix of on and off-road driving, you can also consider purchasing all-terrain tires.

You can have a look at rugged terrain tires that come with the benefits of mud- terrain and all-terrain tires if you drive equally on paved roads and challenging trails. The larger tread blocks and deep grooves in all these tires maximize traction and enhance durability. Mud terrain tires offer the highest amount of traction and durability among these three types, and you should select the Grabber X3 if you want longer tread life. On the other hand, the Pirelli Scorpion MTR offers drivers higher resistance to chips, cuts, and punctures.

Which one should you choose?

To sum up, the Pirelli Scorpion MTR and the General Grabber X3 are great choices for off-road enthusiasts, each offering unique strengths. The Pirelli Scorpion MTR excels in traction and durability, which makes it a top choice for those looking for better grip and control in challenging terrains. On the other hand, if you prioritize longevity and overall service life, the General Grabber X3 emerges as the better option.

Comparing the prices of the LT285/70R17 tire size, each Pirelli Scorpion MTR costs around $280, while the price of each General Grabber X3 is around $358. For a set of four Pirelli tires, the cost is $1120, whereas the same set of General tires costs $1432 (the difference is $312!).

Based on SimpleScore, you can buy the Pirelli Scorpion MTR if you:

• Drive vehicles like the Toyota Tundra, Nissan Armada, and Ram 1500
• Want superior traction (9.6 vs 8.3)
• Prefer better handling (9.2 vs 8.4)
• Want a more affordable option

You can go for the General Grabber X3 if you:

• Drive vehicles like the Chevrolet Silverado 1500, Ford F-150, and Lincoln Mark LT
• Prioritize durability (8.4 vs 7.6)
• Prefer the General brand

Still not sure which tire to buy? Fortunately, SimpleTire is here to help as our helpful agents are more than happy to assist you in selecting the right tire for your ride and budget.