Pirelli Scorpion MTR vs Mickey Thompson Baja Legend MTZ tires

Since its founding in Milan in 1872, Pirelli Tires has grown to become a well-known worldwide brand because of its innovative spirit, superior high-end production, and strong Italian heritage. Mickey Thompson Tires has been an enthusiast brand since 1963. They are dedicated to creating the best off-road, street, and strip products possible. Pirelli and Mickey Thompson are both involved in producing high-tech performance products for vehicle lovers.

For traction in even the roughest terrain, Pirelli mud terrain tires for light trucks and SUVs have aggressive tread patterns. Durability and traction are provided by the Pirelli Scorpion line of mud terrain tires in mud, sand, rocks, and snow. A great mud-terrain tire, the Pirelli Scorpion MTR is designed for four-wheel-drive cars and provides exceptional grip on sand, mud, loose soil, gravel, and snow while maintaining decent road manners and handling on pavement.

Searching for greater momentum and an edge over competitors In severe off-road conditions, Mickey designed tread-on-the-sidewall for extra traction and pulling strength. The Mickey Thompson Baja Legend MTZ is a mud-terrain tire that is made to fit Jeeps, light trucks, and SUVs. Its Four-Pitch Sidebiter pattern offers more traction on rough terrain while shielding the sidewall from harm.

Even though both tires function incredibly well, is one better than the other? Let's compare the Mickey Thompson Baja Legend MTZ and Pirelli Scorpion MTR tires using SimpleScore to help you determine which tire is ideal for you.

Pirelli Scorpion MTR tires

With its self-cleaning pattern, the Scorpion MTR can effectively remove gravel and mud from the tread and lugs, providing a firm grip on a range of surfaces, including rocks, boulders, sand, dirt, snow, and mud. Its super tough sidewall enhances stability. Large transverse grooves work towards improved traction and grip. In addition, a rubber layer around the bead protects the tire.

With its outstanding traction, superb durability, and good longevity, the Scorpion MTR sports an average SimpleScore of 8.4.

Mickey Thompson Baja Legend MTZ tires

The Baja Legend MTZ is a cutting-edge design that offers solid grip both on and off-road for varied mud terrain performance. On-road tread wear, wet performance, and treadwear endurance are strengthened by the T4 silica-reinforced compound, which also contributes to Mickey Thompson's renowned Sidebiter design components and Powerply 3-Ply sidewall structure, which offer off-road performance, rapid steering response, and stability.

Because of its great durability, traction, and excellent longevity, the Baja Legend MTZ has an average SimpleScore of 8.6.

Pirelli Scorpion MTR vs Mickey Thompson Baja Legend MTZ tires on traction

In muddy and off-road conditions, a good mud-terrain tire should be able to provide exceptional traction. Therefore, traction is crucial for mud-terrain tires.

Boasting an exceptional traction score of 9.6, the Pirelli Scorpion MTR features large transversal grooves and a tough tread compound providing it more traction on slope and better grip on muddy and slippery ground. Its large transversal grooves remove the mud from the tread to improve traction. In addition, a network of sipes also contributes to traction.

The Baja Legend MTZ boasts an aggressive tread design that contributes to a great traction score of 8.2. Its high-void tread pattern, angled shoulder scallops, and varying draft angles effectively drive material such as pebbles, dirt, and other objects out of the tread, ensuring consistent traction even in challenging situations. Its silica-based off-road rubber compound improves wet grip, and its four-pitch sidebiter design increases traction.

When it comes to mud and off-road traction, the Pirelli Scorpion MTR boasts a superior traction score than the Mickey Thompson Baja Legend MTZ.

ADVANTAGE: Pirelli Scorpion MTR.

Pirelli Scorpion MTR vs Mickey Thompson Baja Legend MTZ tires on durability

Durability is crucial for mud-terrain tires as these tires are subjected to continuous abuse from sharp items, such as branches and pebbles, which are commonly seen in off-road environments, causing cuts, punctures, and other damage.

Boasting an excellent durability score of 9.2, the Pirelli Scorpion MTR has a sturdy sidewall that increases stability and durability. It also features a rubber layer around the bead to protect the tires. An aggressive high-void tread, a strong casing, and reinforced sidewalls provide great durability.

On-road tread wear, wet performance, and treadwear endurance are strengthened by the T4 silica-reinforced compound, which also contributes to Baja Legend MTZ’s renowned Sidebiter design components, and Powerply 3-Ply sidewall structure, which offer off-road performance, rapid steering response, and stability giving a great durability score of 8.4.

In terms of durability, the Pirelli Scorpion MTR outperforms the Mickey Thompson Baja Legend MTZ.

ADVANTAGE: Pirelli Scorpion MTR.

Pirelli Scorpion MTR vs Mickey Thompson Baja Legend MTZ tires on longevity

Although the purpose of mud-terrain tires is to provide the best grip and handling in off-road driving situations, tread life is compromised in the process, therefore longevity is an added benefit for a mud-terrain tire.

Although the longevity score is not as high as the traction and handling, the Pirelli Scorpion MTR has a strong casing, reinforced sidewalls, and rim protection, resulting in a good longevity score (7.6).

With an exceptional score of 9.2, the Mickey Thompson Baja Legend MTZ features a silica-based rubber compound that protects the tire from cuts and chips, enhances wet grip, and prevents uneven wear for a longer tread life.

The Mickey Thompson Baja Legend MTZ tires score higher than the Pirelli Scorpion MTR tires in terms of longevity.

ADVANTAGE: Mickey Thompson Baja Legend MTZ.

When to use each

Mud-terrain tires are perfect for off-road activities like rock crawling. They can function in light snow and rain, but they are designed for harsh circumstances such as mud, dirt, gravel, rock, and so on. It is not recommended to use these tires for daily driving.

Which one should you choose?

So which all-terrain tire is better? The Mickey Thompson Baja Legend MTZ tires have a higher SimpleScore than the Pirelli Scorpion MTR tires. In terms of handling and traction, the Pirelli Scorpion MTR performs better than the Mickey Thompson Baja Legend MTZ. But the Baja Legend MTZ gets excellent scores for longevity. Let's look at tire prices to see if there is a difference in this area to help you make a decision.

Their prices barely differ from one another. The minimum price per tire for Mickey Thompson Baja Legend MTZ tires is $237.96, but the minimum price for Pirelli Scorpion MTR tires is $240.96. This suggests that the minimum cost of a set of four tires from the Pirelli Scorpion MTR is $963.84, whereas the minimum cost of a set of four tires from the Mickey Thompson Baja Legend MTZ is $951.84.

Based on SimpleScore, you should choose the Pirelli Scorpion MTR if you:

• Drive four-wheel drive vehicles like the Hummer H3.
• Want better handling
• Desire superior traction.
• Look for great performance that is consistent with a premium brand.

In contrast, you should purchase the Mickey Thompson Baja Legend MTZ if you:

• Drive SUVs like the Land Rover Defender, light trucks like the Dodge Ram 1500, and Jeeps like the Jeep Wrangler.
• Are looking for a longer-lasting mud-terrain tire
• Want a more affordable tire

Differentially, the Pirelli Scorpion MTR and the Mickey Thompson Baja Legend MTZ are both great mud-terrain tires. Whichever option you ultimately decide on will rely on your vehicles and the factors that are most important to you, such as price, handling, traction, and longevity.

Still not sure which tire to buy? Fortunately, SimpleTire is here to help as our helpful agents are more than happy to assist you in selecting the right tire for your ride and budget.