Pirelli Scorpion MTR vs Toyo Open Country M/T tires

Characteristics like rim protection, a robust casing, and reinforced sidewalls are essential for mud-terrain tires to perform all their functions. You’ll find many of them with an aggressive tread, one that features self-cleaning properties for removing debris such as mud, sand, and dirt along the way. Pirelli is an older manufacturer, as its first US tire rolled out in 1922 after WW1, but it is relatively new in the mud-terrain tire category.

The Italian manufacturer has been commonly associated with ultra-high performance tires over the years, but the Scorpion MTR is a serious effort in manufacturing tires that can withstand tremendous abuse on difficult off-road terrain. Given below is a detailed comparison between the Pirelli Scorpion MTR and Toyo Open Country M/T, with the latter having a reputation for making good-looking tires for enthusiasts. The use of either of these tires makes a regular light truck or SUV feel more capable in off-road areas. Go through this comparison to see which of the Scorpion MTR vs Evolution MT tires would be ideal for your vehicle.

Pirelli Scorpion MTR tires

Despite being a mud-terrain tire, the Pirelli Scorpion MTR has a strong sidewall and is spongy. We have seen that it is not as noisy as many people on the internet may claim, and its design makes it appropriate for 4WD SUVs and trucks. To distinguish and symbolize the brand, a Scorpion is etched on the tire sidewall. When a car goes over bumps, the rigid sidewall gives off its actual color and gives a firmer ride. The tire will feel sufficiently smooth both on and off the highway. A system of treads and grooves helps to remove mud and debris in part. These mud-terrain tires also include sipes for better traction and longer wear. With its distinct rubber compound and excellent tread depth, the tire is good for an average SimpleScore of 8.4.

Toyo Open Country M/T tires

The majority of Toyo tires are produced in a cutting-edge plant located in Bartow County, GA, with the corporation being established in 1966 and its US headquarters in Costa Mesa, California. Toyo products are recognized for regular use by enthusiasts, racers, and regular drivers alike. Strong and with a sturdy design, the Toyo Open Country M/T tire can resist shocks on a variety of surfaces, including ordinary highways, mud, and snow. These tires were found to be most suitable on full-size pickup trucks. With the help of deep sipes, it can provide confident traction on wet surfaces. Compared to most mud-terrain tires on the market today, you'll find that these are quieter. To top it all, the aggressive tread design that comprises hook-shaped blocks looks good.

Pirelli Scorpion MTR vs Toyo Open Country M/T tires on traction

Large transversal grooves and an aggressive high-void tread help the Pirelli Scorpion MTR remove dirt and debris, keeping a clear part of the tire available for optimal traction at all times. Along with a very deep step, the extensive network of sipes here helps to increase grip. Self-cleaning properties of the tread enable the tire to remove mud, sand, and other debris for consistent traction on the move. The Scorpion MTR can provide traction on mud, sand, gravel, and snow, and scores an exceptional average traction SimpleScore of 9.6.

On the other hand, the Toyo Open Country M/T features deep sipes in the tread pattern for great grip on wet surfaces. Much like the Scorpion MTR, it too features self-cleaning properties that help mud, stones, and dirt get pushed out, resulting in better snow traction. The aggressive tread design with hook-shaped blocks provides better off-road traction while ensuring suitable on-road performance. Based on the above, the Open Country M/T gets a phenomenal average traction SimpleScore of 9.8.

ADVANTAGE: Toyo Open Country M/T

Pirelli Scorpion MTR vs Toyo Open Country M/T tires on durability

The smooth and comfortable Pirelli Scorpion MTR tires provide a ride that mixes soft and firm characteristics. There is a little increase in tread depth compared to the Open Country M/T. Its tough construction keeps it sturdy on various surfaces, and the combination of its reinforced sidewalls and rim guard provides exceptional endurance. The reinforced sidewall of this tire is responsible for great stability at highway speeds. Additionally, this tire is suitable for light trucks and SUVs with 4x4 and receives a great average durability SimpleScore of 9.2.

Compared to the above, the Toyo Open Country M/T features a 3-ply construction for high durability and performance, which also boosts handling performance on and off the road. The tough polyester construction and high turn-up, along with the tread depth, provide superior control and handling on paved roads and challenging off-road conditions while also increasing impact resistance. We found the tire to be suitable for an awesome average durability SimpleScore of 9.4.

ADVANTAGE: Toyo Open Country M/T

Pirelli Scorpion MTR vs Toyo Open Country M/T tires on longevity

Some of the aspects that make the Pirelli Scorpion MTR last long include its tough internal structure, tread design, large transversal grooves, and rugged tread compound. It is the quality of the rubber and tread compound that matters, enabling the Scorpion MTR to last long and secure an average longevity SimpleScore of 7.6.

On the other hand, Toyo Open Country M/T is slightly better and is designed to serve for a longer period, thanks to its polyester construction that ensures long tread life through protection on off-road terrain. This tire is suitable for an average longevity SimpleScore of 8.8.

ADVANTAGE: Toyo Open Country M/T

When to use each

Both, the Scorpion MTR and the Open Country M/T belong to the mud-terrain category, and therefore, they are suitable for use on off-road terrain, which includes mud, sand, dirt, rocks, and gravel. However, these tires are not Three Peak Mountain Snowflake certified and should not be used in winter weather conditions, when the temperature is below 45 degrees Fahrenheit.

Which one should you choose?

Pirelli is commonly known to make the most expensive tires in a lot of cases, but the Toyo tire is likely to be more expensive for certain sizes. While prices for the Pirelli Scorpion MTR are $235.97 ($943.88 for 4), the Toyo Open Country M/T starts from $241.61 (966.44 for 4).

Summarizing the above comparison, you must choose the Pirelli Scorpion MTR if:

• You desire a tire that is effective on slopes
• You need ride quality that is a mix of soft and hard
• You are primarily looking at mud traction

In contrast, here are the reasons that would make you choose the Toyo Open Country M/T:

• You want the tire that looks better
• You want a more durable tire
• You want more confident traction
• You want the tire with a greater load-carrying capacity

Still not sure which tire to buy? Fortunately, SimpleTire is here to help, and our helpful agents are more than happy to assist you in selecting the right tire for your ride and budget.