Vercelli II vs Kelly Edge Touring A/S tires

All-season tires are specially developed to provide year-round traction and performance along with comfortable rides on paved roads. Go out to the real or virtual market and you’ll find that these tires are forever in demand. With them, you won’t have to own an extra set of tires unless you live in a cold area with 6 or more months of moderate to heavy snow. The all-season tires from manufacturers Vercelli and Kelly battle it out in our comparison today. Incidentally, though Vercelli is a brand owned by American Omni Trading Company with tires manufactured in Thailand, Kelly falls under the Goodyear brand and its tires are made in America.

While the Vercelli II has been designed for performance-based coupes and sedans, the Kelly Edge Touring A/S is meant for all types of passenger cars. Both provide limited manufacturer tread life warranties, though the Kelly has an ‘edge’ over the Vercelli tire. There’s a directional tread pattern on the Vercelli tire and a symmetrical tread pattern on the Kelly, possibly making the former better at dry and wet traction. Tread depths on both tires are very similar. We have rated the tires based on our proprietary grading system SimpleScore which allows tires to get 1-10 numerical scores based on parameters such as longevity, handling, and traction. Find out more details by the end of this Vercelli II vs Edge Touring A/S tires comparison to know the most suitable option for your vehicle.

Vercelli II tires

The Vercelli II is a great purchase for users who prefer to drive on all-season tires but wish to experience enthusiastic performances from their performance-oriented coupes and sedans. It is not as great at handling as a UHP (Ultra-High Performance) tire but gets close, with its main benefits being year-round performance and traction, along with a generous limited manufacturer warranty. Expect the double-center rib design to help increase stability and braking performance at high speeds. A computer-optimized design reduces road noise and vibrations, resulting in a smooth and quiet ride.

Higher tread depth makes sense, given the proximity of the traction SimpleScores for the two tires. The Vercelli II was found suitable for a decent average SimpleScore of 8.1.

Kelly Edge Touring A/S tires

Sweeping grooves and a symmetrical tread pattern on the Kelly Edge Touring A/S provide great traction, especially on wet roads. Additionally, you will get a more confident grip through biting tread block edges. A silica-rich tread compound and angled tread blocks help minimize uneven wear for long tread life. The limited manufacturer tread life warranty here is more than the Vercelli tire and its details will be available shortly. The tread depth on both the tires is the same. We found the Kelly tire suitable for an average SimpleScore of 8.2.

Vercelli II vs Kelly Edge Touring A/S tires on traction

Expect the Vercelli II to exhibit superior traction due to its high tread depth, smart tread pattern, and sipe technology. A directional tread pattern allows this tire to stick to the surface while surging ahead. As per our tests, the Vercelli II was found good enough for an average traction SimpleScore of 7.8.

On the other hand, sweeping grooves on the Kelly Edge Touring A/S manage to evacuate slush and water from the tread while minimizing hydroplaning to generate good wet traction. Angled tread blocks and the silica tread compound also help increase grip, leading to an average traction SimpleScore of 7.5.

ADVANTAGE: Vercelli II

Vercelli II vs Kelly Edge Touring A/S tires on handling

You’ll find the Vercelli II to be a performance-based all-season tire with features such as a twin-type center rib design for high-speed capabilities and better braking performance. It sports W and Y speed ratings, demonstrating proof of its ability to handle rapid pace. The Vercelli II empowers you to enjoy spirited drives on performance-based sedans and coupes without burning holes in your pockets. Based on the above, we have awarded the Vercelli tire with an average handling SimpleScore of 8.6.

While Kelly’s symmetric tread pattern enhances handling prowess, the tread depth is responsible for good contact with the road. The Edge Touring A/S showcases a stable footprint because of sturdy tread blocks and the silica tread compound. This is an all-season tire with H, T, and V-speed ratings, making it slower than the Vercelli II. We found the Kelly Edge Touring A/S suitable for an average handling SimpleScore of 8.0.

ADVANTAGE: Vercelli II

Vercelli II vs Kelly Edge Touring A/S tires on longevity

Vercelli backs its tire with a 45,000 mile limited manufacturer tread life warranty, along with a no-questions-asked, 25/365 free replacement limited protection policy. It is able to garner an average longevity SimpleScore of 8.1. As opposed to the above, the silica tread compound and angled tread blocks on the Kelly tire result in more uniform wear. The symmetrical tread pattern is also useful in extending tread life and a limited manufacturer tread life warranty of 65,000 miles is available. Alongside the above warranty, Kelly offers its customers a 45-day satisfaction guarantee and a highway auto and light truck tire replacement limited warranty. The Kelly Edge Touring A/S manages to earn an excellent average longevity SimpleScore of 9.0.

ADVANTAGE: Kelly Edge Touring A/S

When to use each

Searching for reasonably priced choices makes sense for consumers who use all-season tires for their daily commutes. The best part about this comparison is that both the Vercelli and Kelly tires fit into this category. Not only do they immediately eliminate the requirement to store an extra set during bad weather, but they're also available at very reasonable prices, as you shall soon see. Additionally, limited manufacturer tread life warranties on them are responsible for greater peace of mind. While the Vercelli is meant to be fitted on performance-oriented sedans and coupes, the Kelly tire is built for different types of passenger cars.

Which one should you choose?

The Vercelli II is an ideal tire for those who want to corner and drive hard but want greater performance and traction benefits than the usual UHP tires. While it scores higher in terms of traction and handling, the Kelly tire has the upper hand when it comes to longevity. If you notice closely, the difference in the average traction SimpleScores is very low, and this brings us to the next part of this comparison, the price.

We compared the starting prices of the two tires and here’s what we found. The Vercelli II is available for roughly $65 ($260 for 4) as compared to $94 per tire ($470 for 4) for the Kelly tire.

Given below are the reasons to choose the Vercelli II:

• The need to extract better handling performance from your vehicle
• Better braking performance
• Better traction
• You want the less expensive tire

Compared to the above, here’s why you should consider the Kelly Edge Touring A/S:

• You want the higher longevity and the greater limited manufacturer tread life warranty
• You want lesser treadwear for a longer life
• You want a suitable replacement warranty for light truck tires
• You want the tire with a greater brand presence

Still not sure which tire to buy? Fortunately, SimpleTire is here to help as our helpful agents will be more than happy to assist you in selecting the right tire for your ride and budget.